Thursday, January 8, 2009

Some thoughts while reading Alison's blog

The Baha'i modernist worldview
http://meditationsonbahaullah.blogspot.com/2008/09/bahai-modernist-worldview.html
And because Baha'is are stuck in a Guardian time warp, they still see the faith in a modernist way. Key features of this include: a centralised administration that wields absolute authority using the ideology that the administration is, exclusively, the Baha'i Faith. This is justified on the basis of a self-serving, narrow interpretation of the covenant, backed up with the idolatrous doctrine of infallibility. All those wishing to join are persuaded to accept this claim, encouraged to put all their resources into carrying out the centralised plans, and indoctrinated to believe that there is no salvation outside this realm. All activity must take place within the acceptable spheres of participation; those who follow their own star are ostracised and those who speak out in a persuasive way are disenrolled.
I'm considering how I might explain all that to a Baha'i in the middle of it all who doesn't see it.

I don't imagine that anyone would disagree that the House of Justice wields absolute authority in the current practice of the Baha'i community. For "the ideology that the administration is, exclusively, the Baha'i Faith," I might give examples of Auxiliary Board members and assistants depreciating any initiative that is not derived from the goals and plans of the House of Justice. For "self-serving, narrow interpretation of the Covenant," I might discuss the popular view of reducing the Covenant to the infallibility of the central figures and the House of Justice, and shunning people they call Covenant breakers. It seems obvious to me how that could be self-serving for the central figures and the House of Justice. To show how narrow it is, I would invite the person to study Abdu'l-Baha'is Will and Testament with me, to see what else it says besides that.

For "idolatrous doctrine of infallibility," I might give examples of people using the writings of the House of Justice for guidance and inspiration in preference to those of Baha'u'llah, including one person who said in an Internet discussion "I don't care what Baha'u'llah said. I only care what the House of Justice says He said."

I don't imagine anyone would disagree that all those wishing to join are persuaded to accept this claim, and encouraged to put all their resources into carrying out the centralized plans. I'm wondering now how many might see something wrong with this. Because people aren't protesting, doesn't mean they don't see anything wrong with it. It might mean that they think it would be wrong to protest, or even to question it. They might equate popular views of infallibility with those of the central figures. They might think it would be wrong to question them. They might imagine that monopolization of people's time, and the depreciation of initiatives outside of the plans, are coming from the institutions, which is partly true. They might imagine that it would be wrong to do otherwise, or even question it.

For "indoctrinated to believe that there is no salvation outside this realm," I might point to some parts of the Ruhi courses.

"All activity must take place within the acceptable spheres of participation; those who follow their own star are ostracized and those who speak out in a persuasive way are disenrolled."

I imagine most people have seen examples of Auxiliary Board members and assistants depreciating initiatives not explicitly set in the framework. I would have no trouble giving examples of people who have been ostracized for following their own star, and disenrolled after speaking out.

Continuing through the blog:

"A crucial idea that helps to prop up this ideological structure is the argument that the term 'unenrolled Baha'i' is an oxymoron (a contradiction in terms) - to be a Baha'i, one must be a member of the Baha'i community."

That's so ironic. At the same time, it is popular among Baha'is to call people Baha'is who have not yet joined, but who agree with some of our popular ideology.

The idea that people who have left the Faith can not be Baha'is might come at least partly from the idea that there can be no schism in the Baha'i Faith. Seeing people who have rejected the community calling themselves Baha'is might seem like a contradiction to that, especially when they encourage and support each other. One way out of the dilemma is to say that they are not Baha'is.

"Don't glance out the window, keep facing straight ahead, don't lose your chance. I swear, I've spent nearly three decades running around in a panic because of that quote"

I've suffered a lot from that, and I've seen many others suffering from it. I eventually came out of it, and I've seen many others do that, too.

"I'm going to follow my own star; I'm going to fulfil my duties to Baha'u'llah according to my spiritual calling; I'm going to do things I would never have done had I remained a member of the Baha'i community; and I'm going to discover things about myself I wouldn't have discovered otherwise."

Yes, yes, please do! Make your own kind of music! Sing your own special song! And keep encouraging others to do the same!

"And one day - it'll come - the Baha'i administration will realise that it needs to get out of the world of thought, stop indoctrinating its members according to its self-serving ideology, and get down to the virtuous business of making good law."

I've seen some people in Internet discussions about Baha'i social and theological issues, who seem to imagine that any idea which has ever received unfavorable attention from the House of Justice has to be discarded, or that it's wrong for any of us to promote any ideas that we see as contrary to the views of one of the central figures or the House of Justice. That seems very unhealthy to me, and if that's a popular view in Baha'i studies, it might seriously impede our progress. I'm not sure how popular it is. I've seen articles in Baha'i Studies reviews that don't seem to be hampered in that way. I have seen that view poisoning every Baha'i Internet discussion, and it was a factor in the decision not to include the Service of Women paper in the Bahá'í Library Online.

". . . get down to the virtuous business of making good law."

I've sometimes wondered how a person can imagine that the only function of Baha'u'llah's House of Justice is to make laws, other than by blinding himself to everything else Baha'u'llah, Abdu'l-Baha and Shoghi Effendi say about it. Now I can see it as the best way some people have found to counteract the disabling effects of some popular Baha'i views of the Covenant.

Rediscovering Baha'u'llah

I've always had trouble trying to describe the thoughts and feelings that lead to me wanting to rediscover Baha'u'llah. One way is by reference to this:
From the sweet-scented streams of Thine eternity give me to drink, O my God, and of the fruits of the tree of Thy being enable me to taste, O my Hope! From the crystal springs of Thy love suffer me to quaff, O my Glory, and beneath the shadow of Thine everlasting providence let me abide, O my Light! Within the meadows of Thy nearness, before Thy presence, make me able to roam, O my Beloved, and at the right hand of the throne of Thy mercy, seat me, O my Desire! From the fragrant breezes of Thy joy let a breath pass over me, O my Goal, and into the heights of the paradise of Thy reality let me gain admission, O my Adored One! To the melodies of the dove of Thy oneness suffer me to hearken, O Resplendent One, and through the spirit of Thy power and Thy might quicken me, O my Provider! In the spirit of Thy love keep me steadfast, O my Succorer, and in the path of Thy good-pleasure set firm my steps, O my Maker! Within the garden of Thine immortality, before Thy countenance, let me abide for ever, O Thou Who art merciful unto me, and upon the seat of Thy glory stablish me, O Thou Who art my Possessor! To the heaven of Thy loving-kindness lift me up, O my Quickener, and unto the Day-Star of Thy guidance lead me, O Thou my Attractor! Before the revelations of Thine invisible spirit summon me to be present, O Thou Who art my Origin and my Highest Wish, and unto the essence of the fragrance of Thy beauty, which Thou wilt manifest, cause me to return, O Thou Who art my God!
(Baha'u'llah, Prayers and Meditations by Baha'u'llah, p. 257)

I've always imagined that turning to God would feel more and more like that. Sweet-scented streams, crystal springs, shadow of providence, fragrant breezes, melodies of the dove, firm steps in a path, abiding in a garden. Was that just an idle fancy? Sometimes I miss feeling that way, and I start thinking that maybe I need to rediscover Baha'u'llah.

I used to have more of some of the feelings I've missed, before I turned Baha'u'llah into an authority figure. I recovered some of that after my dialogue/Talisman adventures, but I'm still a long way from what I'm longing for. Hm. Maybe that's why it's called "longing."

Wednesday, January 7, 2009

Fictional view x.02

Fictional view x.02:
The Baha'i Faith is impeding human progress by diverting some of the people who could do the most good into less beneficial activities, and even harmful ones. Many people who might otherwise be doing a lot more to help improve the world are drawn into the Baha'i Faith by its public face, and then trapped in its delusional, fruitless rat race.
Comments from any direction will be welcome.

Some thoughts while reading "For the betterment of the world"

In Sen's blog: "For the betterment of the world"

"'Discouraging active political involvement' on the one hand and preaching 'open revolution' on the other are two extremes. But there is a middle ground: the Bahai Teachings encourage political and social activism, where it is possible without partisanship."

In my understanding, "strive to translate that which hath been written into reality and action" (Gleanings p. 249) includes trying to help remedy social ills and improve political systems. I see Baha'u'llah advising us how to go about that without doing more harm than good. As I see it, some popular ways of trying to remedy social ills and improve political systems are self defeating in that they actually help perpetuate and sometimes even aggravate the underlying causes of social ills and abusive behavior of political systems. Current Baha'i policies against involvement in contentious politics might be a result of consultation in Baha'i institutions about how to apply that advice from Baha'u'llah. That consultation would of course include consideration of how it was applied by Abdu'l-Baha and Shoghi Effendi.

"The Bahais are intended to be in the party of progress, the party for the betterment of human condition, and they share this stance with many people of all religions."

Exactly. As I see it, one of the things Baha'is need to do, to help end global violence, is to learn to treat people of all religions, and non-religious people who are working to improve the world, as equal partners in that enterprise.

Sen concludes:

"When we look at what Abdu’l-Baha and Shoghi Effendi said and did, as regards politics and the Bahais’ role in it, we need to consider which kind of society they are talking about: a premodern society with a weak state and no politics, or a society of the modern age, with a strong ideological state and politics that dominate life and intrude into civil spheres — and then we need to apply the principles, not the detailed rules, to whatever more-or-less postmodern state we are dealing with ourselves. The stark choice between 'discouraging active political involvement' and preaching open revolution is one which we face in only the worst kind of modernist state, which is an abnormal condition for a human society."

I don't imagine that the possibilities are ever reduced to those two, even in the worst kind of modernist state. Also, the possibilities are different for different people, and we always need different people doing different things, complementing and reinforcing each other's efforts. There are always some people in a position to directly and personally influence the behavior of governments, or counteract its harmful effects, and some popular kinds of activism might help, or they might get in the way. And even if they help, that doesn't mean that there is no better way for anyone to help, or that anyone who doesn't jump on that bandwagon or wear that uniform is wrong. There might be other things some people can do that will help even more, and make better use of their interests, capacities, resources and time.

"and then we need to apply the principles, not the detailed rules"

That brings up what I said in my fictional view in an earlier post, that the biggest obstacle to progress in the Baha'i community is worship of the administration. That includes blind resistance to changing any administrative policies or practices initiated by Abdu'l-Baha or Shoghi Effendi.

Going back to an earlier part of Sen's post, it looks to me like he's equating Baha'u'llah's "ever-advancing civilization," "reformation of this age," rehabilitating "the fortunes of mankind," "betterment of the world" and "reconstruct the world" with what he calls the program of "the party of progress."

As I see it, Baha'u'llah's "betterment of the world" is not synonymous with any program of any party, including Sen's "party of progress," and it never will be. In my understanding, Baha'u'llah's "betterment of the world" is far, far better than any program anyone can imagine now, and necessarily in some ways contrary to everyone's ideas of progress.

As I see it, equating Baha'u'llah's "betterment of the world" with any fixed ideas of progress can have detrimental consequences for anyone who does so, and for the world. At the same time, in my view, we can serve Baha'u'llah's purposes much better if we have some concrete ideas about what we're aiming for. For some people, whatever Sen means by the program of the party of progress might serve that purpose very well. It becomes detrimental if we depreciate people whose ideas are contrary to ours, or if our ideas are not continually evolving in a context of learning from Baha'u'llah, and serving Him.

Tuesday, January 6, 2009

Fictional view x.01 (continued)

Fictional view x.01

I'm not sure now that the Baha'i Faith ever was the progressive force I thought it was when I first joined, or that it ever will be. If it ever will be, there's no telling how long it will take. I'm still hoping that it will be, and I'd like to help move it in that direction, by awakening its members to what has happened and what is happening to the community, and by bringing to their attention the possibilities that I see, as far as possible in the face of campaigns of censorship and repression, and of vilification against those of us who are trying to do that.

The administration of the Baha'i Faith is now dominated by obsolete and superstitious ideas, and by some people's private interests and personal prejudices, which are impeding the growth and development of the Baha'i community, and preventing it from doing the good that it could be doing. A variety of afflictions including censorship, repression, bandwagon abuse, monopolization of people's time, self-perpetuating leadership, and worship of Baha'i administration prevent the community from learning better ways of thinking and better ways of doing things. Some people who have tried to change that have been penalized, stigmatized and socially isolated from the rest of the community, sometimes by the House of Justice itself.

What are the possibilities for us in this situation?

We need different people doing different things, according to their knowledge, interests and capacities (contrary to what has been popular in the Baha'i community). For example:
- Some of us may find ways to avoid the stigmatization and isolation, and still continue to work for change as members within our local communities.
- Some of us may do better working openly in spite of it, with or without loss of our membership.
- Some of us may do better with an anonymous Internet presence.
- Some of us may do better keeping the rest of us informed, or helping us develop conceptual frameworks for our work.
- Some of us may do better entertaining and stimulating the rest of us in various ways, including clowning, jesting and parodies of opposition and defense.
- Some of us may do better with a conciliatory approach.
- Some of us may do better with a wrathful approach.
- Some of us may do better creating our own models of the kind of community we believe in.

It might be lonely work for some of us because the work we've chosen to do, and way we've chosen to do it, make us look unenlightened, or even foolish, to most or all of the others.

We all have different ideas about what the Baha'i community could or should be doing. Some other people's ideas might even be diametrically opposed to mine. I might disagree with some ideas of some other people, but I don't want any of them to be excluded from consideration in the Baha'i community. Besides promoting my own ideas, I want to help open up the Baha'i community to exploring all of our ideas. I want every person to feel free, and to be free, to promote her ideas. One of the biggest obstacles I see to that is worship of Baha'i administration. Without that, other obstacles might be much easier to overcome.

I'll be looking for ways I can help promote a better view of Baha'i administration among Baha'is.
All comments from any direction will be welcome.

Fictional view x.01

This is for practice. I'm not trying now to approach the point of view of any one person. I just want to practice looking at Baha'u'llah and the Baha'i Faith from some kind of liberation point of view, different from the views I've been using.

Fictional view x.01

I'm not sure now that the Baha'i Faith ever was the progressive force I thought it was when I first joined, or that it ever will be. If it ever will be, there's no telling how long it will take. I'm still hoping that it will be, and I'd like to help move it in that direction, by awakening its members to what has happened and what is happening to the community, and by bringing to their attention the possibilities that I see, as far as possible in the face of the current censorship, repression, and vilification campaigns against those of us who feel this way.
All comments from any direction will be welcome.

Baha'u'llah and liberation of the Baha'i Faith

I would like to post a series of articles looking at Baha'u'llah and the Baha'i Faith from various imaginary points of view that I'm calling "liberation" views for now. Some examples of what I might discuss are Baha'i social issues, wrongdoings of Baha'i institutions, worship of the administration and the House of Justice, What Went Wrong and how it might be corrected. In the process I would be discussing some of the resources that Baha'u'llah says are available to his followers for responding to the situation we're in according to those points of view. I'm hoping to arouse more interest among some people in learning more about Baha'u'llah, and in learning more from Him.

Part of my preparation would be to review some of the writings of Karen, Alison, Sen, Fred and others, about liberation issues. When I discuss Baha'u'llah and the Baha'i Faith from various imaginary points of view, it might look like I'm misrepresenting the views of those people, because I will be trying to approach them as closely as possible, and of course I will miss the mark. Even though I won't attach names to the points of view I'm discussing, and I will present them as imaginary, the better I succeed in what I'm trying to do, the more recognizable they will be as approaches to the views of those people.

One reason I'll be trying to do that is to help them and other people with similar views see the relevance of the resources I'll be discussing to their interests.