Here are some examples to help clarify what I mean by serving the interests of my House of Justice, the interests explicitly stated in its messages, without regard for the possible interests of its members.
The censorship, repression, bandwagon abuse, monopolization of people's time, and worship of Baha'i administration that I've seen discussed in revitalization writings, are all diametrically opposed to the interests of my House of Justice.
- A person who has ideas he thinks are contrary to the views of the House of Justice, and tries to promote them while learning to do it in accordance with Baha'u'llah's purposes and prescriptions, is serving the interests of my House of Justice. That includes promoting the inclusion of women on the House of Justice, gay equality, discontinuation of the review policy, election reform, a Guardian after Shoghi Effendi, and reconsideration of the infallibility, role, functions and policies of the House of Justice, Shoghi Effendi, Abdu'l-Baha and Baha'u'llah.
- Maligning, scolding and pestering anyone, including people who are campaigning against the House of Justice, is diametrically opposed to the interests of my House of Justice.
- Shunning former members is diametrically opposed to the interests of my House of Justice, regardless of the views they're promoting, and regardless of whether they withdrew or were removed.
- Practicing friendship with former members who have been removed by the House of Justice, is serving the interests of my House of Justice.
- Supporting and encouraging members in initiatives that are not derived from community goals, no matter how much they are depreciated by members of Baha'i institutions, is serving the interests of my House of Justice.
- Refusing to participate in Ruhi courses, after sympathetic and self-questioning consideration, is serving the interests of my House of Justice.
- Passing in a ritual round of prayers that you didn't volunteer for, is serving the interests of my House of Justice.
- Refusing to treat any of the writings of the House of Justice as authoritative interpretations of the writings, is serving the interests of my House of Justice.
Saturday, January 10, 2009
Friday, January 9, 2009
Revitalization writings and the framework for action
I started working on an outline of the framework for action, and I thought I might try to make some kind of diagram, along with discussing each of the elements. Now, before that, I might try discussing what some revitalization writings say about the framework for action, and my observations and impressions.
(later) I've been looking for revitalization writings about the framework for action, and was surprised to find very little. I googled "house of justice" and "framework," in a general search, on trb, and on the Web sites of Baha'is Online, Alison Marshall, Baquia, Sen and Priscilla. Here's what I've found so far:
- Baha'i Rants, Ridvan Message 2007 From the House of Justice
- Alison's Meditations on Baha'u'llah, Learning the Lingo
-
I know there have been discussions of the study circles and other elements of the framework, but I'm really surprised to see so few remarks about the framework as a whole. It isn't that new. The terminology goes back at least as far as 2005.
After I discuss what those two articles say about the framework for action, I might look through some more revitalization articles for discussions about the framework or its elements.
(later) I've been looking for revitalization writings about the framework for action, and was surprised to find very little. I googled "house of justice" and "framework," in a general search, on trb, and on the Web sites of Baha'is Online, Alison Marshall, Baquia, Sen and Priscilla. Here's what I've found so far:
- Baha'i Rants, Ridvan Message 2007 From the House of Justice
- Alison's Meditations on Baha'u'llah, Learning the Lingo
-
I know there have been discussions of the study circles and other elements of the framework, but I'm really surprised to see so few remarks about the framework as a whole. It isn't that new. The terminology goes back at least as far as 2005.
After I discuss what those two articles say about the framework for action, I might look through some more revitalization articles for discussions about the framework or its elements.
It might be better to practice and promote serving the interests of my House of Justice
(Revised - See below)
I'll try to explain more what I mean by that, and how it might be better, and give examples of how to do it.
One example of how it might be better is that it might help remedy the defects in the Baha'i community that I've seen discussed in revitalization writings. Another way is that it might help improve the effects of what the Baha'i community is doing for human progress, supposing that what it's doing is not 100% useless or worse. What the Baha'i community is doing might do more good, if it's done in the right way and in the right spirit.
I've already explained that what I mean by "the interests of my House of Justice," are the interests explicitly stated in messages from the Universal House of Justice seated on Mount Carmel.
Some of my revitalization writers might feel like it would be contrary to their interests to practice and promote serving the interests of the House of Justice. As I understand it, one of their interests is for the Baha'i community to be freed from the cruel and disabling effects of worshiping the administration, of sectarian attitudes and practices, and of the pious bandwagon abuse associated with the goals and plans of the House of Justice. They might think that what is needed is for Baha'is to serve the interests of the House of Justice less, not more.
It might help to:
- clarify the distinction I'm making between the interests of my House of Justice and the possible interests of its members.
- look deeper into the worship of the administration, the sectarian attitudes and practices, and the pious bandwagon abuse; and how they might change.
Some examples of how to practice and promote serving the interests of my House of Justice:
- Highlight the interests stated in its messages and distinguish them explicitly from other interests that people might imagine, especially ideas that are currently popular in the Baha'i community.
- Look for ways to help do what it's inviting people to do, and help other people do the same. That would not necessarily mean actually doing them. Many people, after considering what they might do to help, might decide, with good reason, not to use their time and talents that way.
- Describe its interests in different terms that might make more sense to a variety of people.
- Write about what's missing from the current framework for action, in terms of its interests. I imagine that all of the ideas for liberating the Faith that I've seen among my revitalization writers can be expressed in terms of the interests of my House of Justice.
Revisions
(1) 2008-01-10
"One example of how it might be better is that it might do more than anything I've seen my revitalization writers doing, to help remedy the defects in the Baha'i community that I've seen them writing about."
changed to:
"One example of how it might be better is that it might help remedy the defects in the Baha'i community that I've seen discussed in revitalization writings."
I'll try to explain more what I mean by that, and how it might be better, and give examples of how to do it.
One example of how it might be better is that it might help remedy the defects in the Baha'i community that I've seen discussed in revitalization writings. Another way is that it might help improve the effects of what the Baha'i community is doing for human progress, supposing that what it's doing is not 100% useless or worse. What the Baha'i community is doing might do more good, if it's done in the right way and in the right spirit.
I've already explained that what I mean by "the interests of my House of Justice," are the interests explicitly stated in messages from the Universal House of Justice seated on Mount Carmel.
Some of my revitalization writers might feel like it would be contrary to their interests to practice and promote serving the interests of the House of Justice. As I understand it, one of their interests is for the Baha'i community to be freed from the cruel and disabling effects of worshiping the administration, of sectarian attitudes and practices, and of the pious bandwagon abuse associated with the goals and plans of the House of Justice. They might think that what is needed is for Baha'is to serve the interests of the House of Justice less, not more.
It might help to:
- clarify the distinction I'm making between the interests of my House of Justice and the possible interests of its members.
- look deeper into the worship of the administration, the sectarian attitudes and practices, and the pious bandwagon abuse; and how they might change.
Some examples of how to practice and promote serving the interests of my House of Justice:
- Highlight the interests stated in its messages and distinguish them explicitly from other interests that people might imagine, especially ideas that are currently popular in the Baha'i community.
- Look for ways to help do what it's inviting people to do, and help other people do the same. That would not necessarily mean actually doing them. Many people, after considering what they might do to help, might decide, with good reason, not to use their time and talents that way.
- Describe its interests in different terms that might make more sense to a variety of people.
- Write about what's missing from the current framework for action, in terms of its interests. I imagine that all of the ideas for liberating the Faith that I've seen among my revitalization writers can be expressed in terms of the interests of my House of Justice.
Revisions
(1) 2008-01-10
"One example of how it might be better is that it might do more than anything I've seen my revitalization writers doing, to help remedy the defects in the Baha'i community that I've seen them writing about."
changed to:
"One example of how it might be better is that it might help remedy the defects in the Baha'i community that I've seen discussed in revitalization writings."
Revitalization writings and the framework for action
Plan C.1.32g r29.3
I might write a series of articles about some revitalization writings and the framework for action of the House of Justice. By "revitalization writings" I mean some writings of some people who interest me personally, that revolve around defects in the Baha'i community, and what I've been calling "liberation" views.
A series of articles like that might serve several purposes for me at the same time. It could be a way for me to spend time with the authors of those writings, doing things that interest them, in order to deepen my friendships with them. It could be a way for me to improve my practice of some things I want to promote, including serving the interests of my House of Justice, and looking deeper into what other people see, to see what I might be missing.
At the same time I would be writing a series of articles in my Deeds Not Words blog, about the people of Baha and the framework for action, and inviting authors of popular Baha'i blogs to look through them for ideas they can use.
Together, those two projects could be a way for me to help transmit encouragement, support and learning through walls of prejudice and over gulfs of estrangement between people who are interested in Baha'u'llah and the Baha'i Faith.
I might alternate for now between discussing revitalization writings, and discussing the framework for action, independently, but I'm imagining that the two subjects will intertwine progressively.
Some examples of what I might do with the framework for action:
- Outline it
- Discuss each element
- Give examples of how to find ways to help
I might write a series of articles about some revitalization writings and the framework for action of the House of Justice. By "revitalization writings" I mean some writings of some people who interest me personally, that revolve around defects in the Baha'i community, and what I've been calling "liberation" views.
A series of articles like that might serve several purposes for me at the same time. It could be a way for me to spend time with the authors of those writings, doing things that interest them, in order to deepen my friendships with them. It could be a way for me to improve my practice of some things I want to promote, including serving the interests of my House of Justice, and looking deeper into what other people see, to see what I might be missing.
At the same time I would be writing a series of articles in my Deeds Not Words blog, about the people of Baha and the framework for action, and inviting authors of popular Baha'i blogs to look through them for ideas they can use.
Together, those two projects could be a way for me to help transmit encouragement, support and learning through walls of prejudice and over gulfs of estrangement between people who are interested in Baha'u'llah and the Baha'i Faith.
I might alternate for now between discussing revitalization writings, and discussing the framework for action, independently, but I'm imagining that the two subjects will intertwine progressively.
Some examples of what I might do with the framework for action:
- Outline it
- Discuss each element
- Give examples of how to find ways to help
Thursday, January 8, 2009
It might be better to practice and promote serving the interests of my House of Justice
I say "my" House of Justice because it looks to me like what I call the House of Justice is different in practical and consequential ways from what other people call the House of Justice, especially my friends that I'm writing for here, and their detractors.
My House of Justice is not clearly defined. What is clearly defined for me is its interests. Its interests are the ones that are explicitly stated in messages which I imagine have been distributed as messages from the Universal House of Justice, with the approval of the Universal House of Justice seated on Mount Carmel. Examples would be messages on the Web site of a national spiritual assembly, and messages included in the Ocean software library. The interests of my House of Justice and the interests of its members are sharply distinguished in my mind, and can even be diametrically opposed. I try to avoid speculating about any interests other than those explicitly stated.
One way that I practice serving its interests is by studying its messages with these questions in mind:
- What can I learn from this?
- What can I do about it?
I spend more time on parts that look wrong to me, trying to find some honest and fair way to agree with them, and practice and promote them.
As I said, I won't be trying to substantiate these ideas. I'll be trying to explain them.
My House of Justice is not clearly defined. What is clearly defined for me is its interests. Its interests are the ones that are explicitly stated in messages which I imagine have been distributed as messages from the Universal House of Justice, with the approval of the Universal House of Justice seated on Mount Carmel. Examples would be messages on the Web site of a national spiritual assembly, and messages included in the Ocean software library. The interests of my House of Justice and the interests of its members are sharply distinguished in my mind, and can even be diametrically opposed. I try to avoid speculating about any interests other than those explicitly stated.
One way that I practice serving its interests is by studying its messages with these questions in mind:
- What can I learn from this?
- What can I do about it?
I spend more time on parts that look wrong to me, trying to find some honest and fair way to agree with them, and practice and promote them.
As I said, I won't be trying to substantiate these ideas. I'll be trying to explain them.
It might be better to look deeper into what Baha'u'llah says about . . .
It might be better to look deeper into what Baha'u'llah says about the possibilities of human life, and the role of God's manifestations in human well-being and progress.
Here are some examples of what I see Baha'u'llah saying:
1. Turning to Him will improve anyone's life, and anyone's capacity to help improve the world.
2. There is no better way for anyone to help improve the world, than by learning to serve His purposes, in accordance with His prescriptions.
3. There will always be differences between Baha'u'llah's purposes and prescriptions, and everyone's understanding of them.
4. There is no way for the world to move away from today's injustice, cruelty, violence and other ugliness, and towards the best possibilities in human life, that does not include doing everything that Baha'u'llah says needs to be done.
5. Part of what needs to be done can not be done without recognizing Baha'u'llah as everything He claims to be, and turning to Him.
It doesn't matter, for my purposes now, if anyone agrees or disagrees with any of that. Those are examples of what I think people might find by looking deeper into what Baha'u'llah says about the role of God's manifestations in human well-being and progress.
What I mean by looking deeper includes:
- Investigating what Baha'u'llah says about the possibilities of human life, the role of God's manifestations, Baha'u'llah as one of them, and what to do about it.
- Imagining that all of it might be true.
- Considering how to find out if it is all true or not.
- Investigating what Baha'u'llah says about how to find out if it is all true or not.
- Trying to find out if it is all true or not.
Here are some examples of what I see Baha'u'llah saying:
1. Turning to Him will improve anyone's life, and anyone's capacity to help improve the world.
2. There is no better way for anyone to help improve the world, than by learning to serve His purposes, in accordance with His prescriptions.
3. There will always be differences between Baha'u'llah's purposes and prescriptions, and everyone's understanding of them.
4. There is no way for the world to move away from today's injustice, cruelty, violence and other ugliness, and towards the best possibilities in human life, that does not include doing everything that Baha'u'llah says needs to be done.
5. Part of what needs to be done can not be done without recognizing Baha'u'llah as everything He claims to be, and turning to Him.
It doesn't matter, for my purposes now, if anyone agrees or disagrees with any of that. Those are examples of what I think people might find by looking deeper into what Baha'u'llah says about the role of God's manifestations in human well-being and progress.
What I mean by looking deeper includes:
- Investigating what Baha'u'llah says about the possibilities of human life, the role of God's manifestations, Baha'u'llah as one of them, and what to do about it.
- Imagining that all of it might be true.
- Considering how to find out if it is all true or not.
- Investigating what Baha'u'llah says about how to find out if it is all true or not.
- Trying to find out if it is all true or not.
It might be better to . . .
I want to try to describe and explain my feeling that it might be better for some of my friends, and for human progress, for them to:
- look deeper into what Baha'u'llah says about God's role and the role of His manifestations in human well-being and progress.
- practice and promote serving the interests of my House of Justice.
I won't be trying to substantiate those ideas. I will be trying to explain what I mean well enough that my friends can respond in ways that will help me see what they see, that I might be missing. I would like them to look deeper into what Baha'u'llah says, looking for possibilities they might be missing for improving their lives and improving the world. I'm trying to improve my practice of what I'm promoting, so I want to try to look deeper into what they're thinking and doing, looking for possibilities that I might be missing.
- look deeper into what Baha'u'llah says about God's role and the role of His manifestations in human well-being and progress.
- practice and promote serving the interests of my House of Justice.
I won't be trying to substantiate those ideas. I will be trying to explain what I mean well enough that my friends can respond in ways that will help me see what they see, that I might be missing. I would like them to look deeper into what Baha'u'llah says, looking for possibilities they might be missing for improving their lives and improving the world. I'm trying to improve my practice of what I'm promoting, so I want to try to look deeper into what they're thinking and doing, looking for possibilities that I might be missing.
Labels:
God,
House of Justice,
manifestations,
progress,
well-being
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)